Which features make an escalation task a real test of agent judgement?
A checklist for separating tasks that test delegated-authority judgement from tasks that only look up a threshold and return a label.
Use this list to check whether a proposed task is testing escalation judgement rather than simple classification.
- The authority limit depends on at least two fields, such as product and aggregate exposure. - A related record elsewhere in the case changes the answer. - More than one next approver exists, and only one is correct. - The handover requires a rationale, a policy reference and attached evidence. - Some cases sit inside the agent's authority and should not be referred. - The senior reviewer's possible outcomes include conditions and return-for-information, not only approve or decline. - The case history records earlier referrals, so repeated or circular escalation can be detected.
A task that meets only the first item is closer to a threshold lookup. Tasks meeting most of the list start to resemble how delegated authority works in a credit team, where the decision, the route and the paperwork are all assessed.
Whether a given task pack covers these items is something to confirm in a sample before relying on it, and a sample is also the place to see how many of the cases meet more than one item at once.
Use the list to reject tasks that reduce to a threshold lookup and keep those where decision, route and paperwork are all assessed.
- Audience:
- Evaluation teams
- Content type:
- Checklist
- Buyer question:
- What it is and why it matters
Content release: r-a220eb6e099b243b
Related questions
- Why test escalation separately from approve and decline decisions?
- What does a real escalation look like when the trigger sits in a related record?
- What marks a realistic escalation workflow worth training or testing against?
- What tool actions and linked records does an escalation agent work with?
- Why does escalation matter when building agents for credit decisions?
- How does an escalation map onto an environment's state machine and tool actions?