What does a scoped pilot look like from the first call to a decision to widen it?
An evaluation lead scopes a utility connection pilot, reviews a first sample, finds an ambiguous policy clause and decides how to widen scope. The scenario shows the loop.
An evaluation lead at a model lab wants to test whether an agent holds work correctly when an approval has open conditions. They ask MirrorFirm for a pilot in one domain: utility network connections.
In the scoping call, the lead and a MirrorFirm contact settle five things. The domain is commercial connection approvals. The records are approvals, conditions, evidence and work orders, delivered as JSONL. The failure modes are outdated evidence, a condition added after approval, and a request to energise before clearance. The environment needs three tools and a reset. The lab's own team will review the sample.
The first sample contains a small set of cases such as CONN-3318, where a network planner approves a connection subject to a revised site plan and a protection settings sign-off. Each case has policy text, a timeline, a label and a grader.
The lab's reviewers read the cases and flag one policy clause that is ambiguous. They run a current model and find that it releases the work order in cases where the sign-off is missing. They decide to widen the pilot to a second domain, and ask for an added group of cases where approvals lapse.
**What it teaches:** a pilot is a bounded loop of scope, sample, review and adjust. The aim is a decision about whether and how to proceed, with licence terms, volume and delivery agreed separately.
A pilot is a bounded loop of scope, sample, review and adjust, ending in a decision rather than a commitment to volume.
- Audience:
- Model labs
- Content type:
- Scenario
- Buyer question:
- Scope and getting started
Content release: r-a220eb6e099b243b
Related questions
- What does a first pilot review look like for a referral-processing agent team?
- How is generated conditional-approval material licensed, and what limits apply?
- What should a pilot request include so the first sample can be judged quickly?
- How should I scope a first pilot for conditional-approval material?
- How do I wire a pilot sample into my agent harness for a first run?
- What should I ask for in a first sample or pilot?